akizuki_ryou vs akizuki_ryou

BUR #5480 has been rejected.

create alias akizuki_ryou -> akizuki_ryou_(idolmaster)
remove alias akizuki_ryou -> akizuki_ryou_(idolmaster)
rename akizuki_ryou_(artist) -> akizuki_ryou

from howto:artist:

Avoid adding the qualifier "_(artist)" after the artist name

From what I understand real name artists take priority.

Couldn't rename due to girl exceeding 200 posts. Please help me verify this BUR will work as intended

Reply

nonamethanks

almost 4 years ago

Given that the character has over a thousand post and the artist is pretty minor, I don't see the point in changing things to give precedence to the artist. The _(artist) qualifier is discouraged but if there's no other way to name the tag without resorting to nonsense then we gotta keep it.

Also compare the google results, if you search for "akizuki ryou" the results are all about the im@s character.

Reply

testingmmmmm

almost 4 years ago

nonamethanks said:
Given that the character has over a thousand post and the artist is pretty minor, I don't see the point in changing things to give precedence to the artist. The _(artist) qualifier is discouraged but if there's no other way to name the tag without resorting to nonsense then we gotta keep it.
Also compare the google results, if you search for "akizuki ryou" the results are all about the im@s character.

I agree with the reasoning; I had just assumed artists take priority independently of case. However I disagree with the last point, my google searches show first the girl, then the mangaka but the name in hiragana returns consistently the mangaka:

https://www.google.com/search?q=%E3%81%82%E3%81%8D%E3%81%A5%E3%81%8D%E3%82%8A%E3%82%87%E3%81%86

Also we know that google caters results based on your history so we can try with another search engine.

But yeah it's clear that for danbooru purposes the imas girl is the senior tag

Reply