@葉月: The title "win comments" is stupid, because it...

葉月
2009-12-08T16:53:28-05:00

The title "win comments" is stupid, because it suggests a contest in which you can win comments.

As for bureaucracy, the idea is someone steps up, we get to see if they're not totally stupid, and if not, they get their own little request thread in which people can drop nominations and that's all. This way we could avoid it degenerating into a total cesspool of "lololol narruto joke". And in the name of avoiding any more process than necessary, I submit the keeper should get an absolute and final say over what goes in, with any discussion in the thread being expressly forbidden.

All that's assuming someone suitable does step up and assumes the responsibility for maintaining it. I'm certainly not gonna care enough actually to organise the thing.