@Ylimegirl: > Knowledge_Seeker said: > > In regards to the...

Ylimegirl
2025-08-06T01:22:58-04:00

Knowledge_Seeker said:

In regards to the split theme issue...I'm tempted to argue this should imply split theme, due to the main gimmick being two connected scenarios juxtaposed against each other in such a way that they appear as separate worlds, in such a way split theme applies, but considering you mentioned having a bone to pick with split theme, that'd require more deliberation.

My gripes with split theme is probably a minority one, since I personally it should be used for depictions of subjects that are actually, well, split. I personally don't think before and after, different reflection, or symmetry alone should qualify for the way I interpret the tag in my head.

With that in mind, my thoughts on the posts under pool:3209 split_theme are that I wouldn't consider post #2909062 or post #1587372 reflected worlds, just split theme; post #7211219 and post #8555625 are both reflected worlds but I wouldn't consider either a split theme, post #873844 qualifies for both; and then post #7295933 is maybe split theme but definitely not reflected worlds. That's just my opinion though. I don't know if the tags have changed since I made that BUR months ago which may affect my current take on the situation. (also, unrelated but imo post #5104236 is probably just different reflection. I don't think it should be in this pool/tag.)