incoming_stomping

Posted under Tags

trapster77

BUR #50139 has been rejected.

mass update imminent_stomping -favgroup:48483 -> incoming_stomping -imminent_stomping

so i started adding tags like these to the imminent stomping tag

because they were scattered around trampling, stepping, stepped on, imminent kick, incoming kick and presenting foot, but now i realize that the tag should have been called incoming stomping instead since it's directed at the viewer. i separated the non-incoming into a favgroup so this BUR will move the posts not in the favgroup

basically the idea is that they should be divided like this

Reply
People of the Book CommentaryRequest LQ Freshblink
Blank User

BUR #50158 has been rejected.

mass update imminent_stomping -favgroup:48483 -> incoming_stomp -imminent_stomping
create alias imminent_stomping -> imminent_stomp

The tag should be renamed so saved searches, blacklists, and wiki information transfer over.

An alias is needed because it has over 200 posts (even more of a reason not to mass update). I'll leave it to someone else to decide whether we want to keep the alias.

Reply
hasu no tokimeki CommentaryRequest Freshblink LQ People of the Book Wellness Bringer01
LQ

I wonder if all the "pov verbing" tags should be renamed to "imminent verb" to reduce ambiguity. "pov stomping" would work but perhaps "pov bullying" and "pov stabbing" should be "incoming bully" and "incoming stab" (similar to incoming attack). Errr... some words work better than others.

Reply
trapster77

LQ said:

I wonder if all the "pov verbing" tags should be renamed to "imminent verb" to reduce ambiguity. "pov stomping" would work but perhaps "pov bullying" and "pov stabbing" should be "incoming bully" and "incoming stab" (similar to incoming attack). Errr... some words work better than others.

the problem is that every straight-on and lots of from below become pov if pov meant just "it looks like the character is interacting with the viewer instead of just looking at the camera"

so the criteria for pov is that you can see the viewer's body like in pov legs and pov hands

in topic #33570 for pov shadow everyone agrees it should imply shadow but not that it should imply pov

basically everyone wants to add a new pov something like topic #33038 "viewfinder pov" that is just the viewfinder user interface as a border but none of these new povs can actually imply pov which kind of sucks imo because people will just start tagging more posts pov that shouldn't be pov

i'd even argue the opposite... that there should be an incoming or incoming action supertag to be used instead of pov when pov doesn't apply

edit: i went ahead and made the BUR #50174 for incoming action and wrote a the viewer wiki to replace all the "pov|the viewer" links on the booru. i don't know about the other verbs but pov stabbing should be incoming stab at least (BUR #50177)

Updated by trapster77

Reply
1