Posted under Tags
BUR #52911 has been rejected.
create implication re:bf_gaiden_~kyoudan_no_kage_to_suna_no_miko~ -> ragnarok_online
Apparently, this is a spinoff of Ragnarok Online according to forum #411278, though I couldn't find any clear evidence.
@kakinade Do you have any sources to prove this is a spinoff?
Blank_User said:
BUR #52911 has been rejected.
create implication re:bf_gaiden_~kyoudan_no_kage_to_suna_no_miko~ -> ragnarok_online
Apparently, this is a spinoff of Ragnarok Online according to forum #411278, though I couldn't find any clear evidence.
@kakinade Do you have any sources to prove this is a spinoff?
This work is a doujin game based on Ragnarok Online.It was created by the circle Asgar Knights (アスガル騎士団), and is introduced on the following sites:
https://ci-en.dlsite.com/creator/1649/article/1426010
https://www.dlsite.com/maniax/work/=/product_id/RJ01268332.html
I apologize for the inconvenience, but I would appreciate it if you could take a look.If I have misunderstood the meaning of "spin-off," I am sorry.
kakinade said:
This work is a doujin game based on Ragnarok Online.It was created by the circle Asgar Knights (アスガル騎士団), and is introduced on the following sites:
https://ci-en.dlsite.com/creator/1649/article/1426010
https://www.dlsite.com/maniax/work/=/product_id/RJ01268332.htmlI apologize for the inconvenience, but I would appreciate it if you could take a look.If I have misunderstood the meaning of "spin-off," I am sorry.
The archived item is a sequel, so the very first work in the series is the following:
https://www.dlsite.com/maniax/work/=/product_id/RJ112559.html
So from what I can gather from these sources, these are all hentai fan games of Ragnarok Online that use some of the same characters such as the female monsters. The original spinoff series is ROBF (Ragnarok Online Battle Fuck), and REBF is a side story to ROBF. That means we probably need a copytag in between, so REBF would imply ROBF, which would imply Ragnarok Online. But is it fine to have 100% overlap between two copytags like that? Should we wait until we get posts from ROBF but not REBF? Or should they all be lumped into ROBF?
However we handle the implications, if a character in a post came from Ragnarok Online, then that tag needs to be added.
Blank_User said:
So from what I can gather from these sources, these are all hentai fan games of Ragnarok Online that use some of the same characters such as the female monsters. The original spinoff series is ROBF (Ragnarok Online Battle Fuck), and REBF is a side story to ROBF. That means we probably need a copytag in between, so REBF would imply ROBF, which would imply Ragnarok Online. But is it fine to have 100% overlap between two copytags like that? Should we wait until we get posts from ROBF but not REBF? Or should they all be lumped into ROBF?
However we handle the implications, if a character in a post came from Ragnarok Online, then that tag needs to be added.
Understood. I'm sorry, I registered it without properly considering the original work (ROBF), so I will add the copy tag.
However, I'm really sorry to say this, but since I've never created a copy tag before, I would appreciate it if you could give me some time to look into it...
All the characters are based on the original Ragnarok Online, so I will also add that tag.
kakinade said:
Understood. I'm sorry, I registered it without properly considering the original work (ROBF), so I will add the copy tag.
However, I'm really sorry to say this, but since I've never created a copy tag before, I would appreciate it if you could give me some time to look into it...
All the characters are based on the original Ragnarok Online, so I will also add that tag.
Since REBF is a derivative work of ROBF, I thought it might be easier to understand if we separated them like the .hack series, but I'm struggling because I don't know how to do it...
I've added the copy tags robf and Ragnarok Online to the REBF side, so if you know how to edit or anything like that, I would greatly appreciate it if you could teach me.
Blank_User said:
I think you should just leave things as they are for now. We still haven't heard from anyone with experience on how messy cases like this should be handled.
Understood. I will revert it back to only the originally registered tag REBF. Sorry for the inconvenience.
BUR #52929 has been rejected.
create implication re:bf_gaiden_~kyoudan_no_kage_to_suna_no_miko~ -> robf
create implication robf -> ragnarok_online
Alternate BUR for creating an implication chain as described above.
BUR #52930 has been approved by @evazion.
create alias re:bf_gaiden_~kyoudan_no_kage_to_suna_no_miko~ -> robf
create implication robf -> ragnarok_online
Alternate BUR for moving everything into ROBF.
kakinade said:
Understood. I will revert it back to only the originally registered tag REBF. Sorry for the inconvenience.
Clearly, you don't understand, as I said to not change anything. If a character is from the main copyright, it should have the tag from that copyright. There is no reason to remove it, or to leave several posts without a copytag.
I am reverting these changes. I will say it again: leave things as they are and let the BURs handle it. Do not change the tags.
Blank_User said:
Clearly, you don't understand, as I said to not change anything. If a character is from the main copyright, it should have the tag from that copyright. There is no reason to remove it, or to leave several posts without a copytag.
I am reverting these changes. I will say it again: leave things as they are and let the BURs handle it. Do not change the tags.
I'm sorry, I completely misunderstood.I will leave it untouched as it is for now.
The bulk update request #52930 (forum #411617) has been approved by @evazion.
The bulk update request #52929 (forum #411616) has been rejected by @evazion.
The bulk update request #52911 (forum #411538) has been rejected by @evazion.
