Suggested tags and a question

Two part topic.

Suggested tags are as follows.

'Certain_death' - For any picture depicting an injury that is certain to kill but has not yet killed the victim of said injury. This would not apply to instant death injuries. Examples include: Busted open head, bullet lodged near heart, poison having penetrated the thoracic cavity, etc.

'Training' - For any picture depicting someone who is teaching another individual a skill or knowledge, regardless of whether that is sexual or not.

'Cat_Fight' - For any picture depicting two or more females fighting, regardless of conditions.

'Imminent_fight' - for any picture depicting the dramatic final moments before a fight actually starts, regardless of conditions.

'Magic_fight' - for any picture depicting two or more persons fighting in which all persons involved in the actual fighting are primarily magic users.

'LoL' - for any picture that is clearly and openly meant to be humorous, regardless of what it depicts.

'Great_Beyond' - For any picture that depicts an afterlife, either the landscape of such an afterlife, the entry into or exit from such an afterlife, or People who are now cannonically dead interacting with still living individuals in any way (though they must be specifically and clearly dead for such a tag to be relevant).

'Dream_sequence' - For any picture that depicts what is clearly and explicitly shown to be a dream of a character, regardless of whether the dream is pleasant or not.

'Aura' - For any picture that shows a characters aura as visible for whatever reason.

Finally, an easy question.

Is it possible if you are not the creator of a pool to comment on all pictures in general in said pool? Should it be?

'Certain_death'
'Training'
'Imminent_fight'

Too subjective

'Cat_Fight'
'Magic_fight'

Not particularly useful

'LoL'

Way too subjective

'Great_Beyond'

Subjective

'Dream_sequence'

Not totally without merit

'Aura'

I thought we had this one. I know we discussed it at least

Finally, an easy question.

Is it possible if you are not the creator of a pool to comment on all pictures in general in said pool? Should it be?

No, yes, add it to the list for the next version of Danbooru

I don't understand how 'Certain_Death' is to subjective. It either fits or it doesn't. I also don't understand how 'Great_Beyond' is subjective. It also either fits or it doesn't.

Where is the list for the next version?

Abyssal_Bleakness said:
I don't understand how 'Certain_Death' is to subjective. It either fits or it doesn't. I also don't understand how 'Great_Beyond' is subjective. It also either fits or it doesn't.

Where is the list for the next version?

"Certain Death" is clearly subjective. The others would probably require too much information external to the image itself.

The list was proverbial.

Well. They seemed like a good idea to me at the time. The tags in general, I mean.

I do still think Dream_sequence is a good idea. I simply posted the topic to gauge public opinion about whether these tags are a good idea or a stupid idea.

Abyssal_Bleakness said:
'LoL' - for any picture that is clearly and openly meant to be humorous, regardless of what it depicts.

That's basically pool #330 (Clever)

'Aura' - For any picture that shows a characters aura as visible for whatever reason.

There already is an aura tag.

zatchii said:
That's basically pool #330 (Clever)
There already is an aura tag.

Also battle aura, which should be aliased.

So weening it totally down to just the ones that have some chance of actually working, it would be just Dream_Sequence.
And what about this idea of a general pool comment option? I think it helps people who build and maintain the pools know what the general populace thinks of a given pool.

Can you find some examples of posts you'd add dream_sequence to that aren't covered by imagining or dreaming?

I'd have to do a thorough search and it would have to be later. I'm going to sleep here not very long from now. It would also likely take a long time. But thats fine.

Abyssal_Bleakness said:
'Certain_death'

dying

'Cat_Fight' - For any picture depicting two or more females fighting

battle + multiple_girls

'Magic_fight'

magic + battle

'Great_Beyond'

spirit, ghost

'Dream_sequence'

dreaming

[/quote]

Well... at least I'm thinking about this stuff and I care. No reason to keep this topic open since its basically been exercised, unless someone has a differing opinion than whats been shown.

Mods - if no posts accrue here in the next little while go ahead and close the topic.

Abyssal_Bleakness said:
'Cat_Fight' - For any picture depicting two or more females fighting, regardless of conditions.

catfight