Tag Alias: cutoff_jeans -> denim_shorts

Aliasing cutoff_jeans -> denim_shorts.

Reason: Denim_shorts already mentions cutoff jeans as a sub-type in its wiki entry.

If it is a sub-type, then shouldn't it be implicated instead of aliased? Also, if something like post #666543 qualifies for cutoff_jeans, then it doesn't seem like it should be implicated (or aliased).

I was going to post pretty much the same thing but cutoffs is already aliased so I couldn't decide. Posts aren't loading for me atm but if that's the one I'm thinking of there must be another tag for it (asymmetrical clothing + jeans perhaps.)

NWF_Renim said:
If it is a sub-type, then shouldn't it be implicated instead of aliased? Also, if something like post #666543 qualifies for cutoff_jeans, then it doesn't seem like it should be implicated (or aliased).

Of course you are correct. I thus would go along with implication... but then the asymmetricality really throws a wrench in the works. So until we find a solution, are we looking at manual addition of denim_shorts where symmetrical cases exist?

Manual, yeah.

I was just thinking that according to the denim shorts wiki, cutoffs is aliased to the former. As I am currently using the cutoff jeans tag, I am thinking that all cutoffs are denim shorts, but not all denim shorts are cutoffs. Does anything need to be changed?

hungkok2007 said: I am thinking that all cutoffs are denim shorts, but not all denim shorts are cutoffs. Does anything need to be changed?

This is what a cutoffs -> denim_shorts alias is saying. I don't think change is needed unless I misunderstood you.

I would therefore humbly submit that the cutoffs alias to denim_shorts should be cancelled, or replaced with an implication. Which is what NWF Renim was advocating in the first place.

I actually think it'd be better to have the tag not fall under denim_shorts, and instead cover the "cutoff" appearance, and thus include even jeans one_pantsleg in which there is clearly the "cutoff" depiction (which appears to be all of them).

The "cutoff" look isn't limited to shorts, there are things like post #73085 (denim skirt) which can exist too. So I think a broader definition for the tag would be the better direction to go.

Removed the cutoffs -> denim_shorts alias.

Okay, I can dig it. So should we go further and alias "cutoff_jeans" to "cutoff" in light of NWF's point?