@user_329668: > glasnost said: > So you two are going to go...

user_329668
2011-02-04T14:25:24-05:00

glasnost said:
So you two are going to go through the pool and keep only the images that you think are good enough? How is this different from a two-person favorites pool?

I never said I would go through it. I was only stating what I thought fit the whole disgustingly adorable concept.

This is my problem with the clean-up idea. If there was any, even the slightest hint of objectivity in the criteria for pool inclusion, people appointing themselves as guardians would be A-OK, because they could then enforce said criteria. Since there's not, though, nobody has any basis to do so except their own personal, subjective judgement, which is not inherently better than anyone else's. Unless one of you got a sword from some strange woman in a pond while I wasn't looking, this is a bad idea.

I guess for this and any subjective pool it might be a good idea to really look at them and set up a group (creator + 8-10 people with good posting habits) and moderate them or not allow them to exist.

Note: They would moderate all the subjective pools.