@Cyberia-Mix: Not the best example indeed but Renim's...

Cyberia-Mix
2011-02-22T18:35:03-05:00

Not the best example indeed but Renim's demonstration was perfect nonetheless (and I unsurprisingly entirely support what he and S1eth said).

Potentially, when deciding whether an umbrella tag is desirable:
> On one hand we have users missing content from counterintuitive tag usages and not checking wikis (not implicating).
> On the other hand we have inability to perform specific searches, and increased odds of undertagged subset tags, also leading to missed content or noise (implicating).
That's safety vs. functionality.

The compromise that users will never be informed enough, and posts will always remain undertagged (eventually forcing you to perform any search at the highest level) is simply not a good stance to me when you have people all over the site constantly working against this.
If we intend all tags to have a wiki, maybe it's time to start blaming users for not looking at them.