The "so_moe_i'm_gonna_die!" tag

Since the concept of moe is subjective, I think we should reserve this for only when a character says that line or something close. Any objections?

Correct. Subjective tags should not be used.

At first I was going to respond saying that I think there's nothing wrong with subjective tags, that it isn't hurting anyone, and that it can be funny at times. But then I realized that since it is subjective, there would be tag-changing wars breaking out, "It's moe!" "No, it's not moe!" "Yes, it's moe!" etc.

abcadeff said: But then I realized that since it is subjective, there would be tag-changing wars breaking out, "It's moe!" "No, it's not moe!" "Yes, it's moe!" etc.

Yeah, that's part of it. Hence the drama over the 'what' tag.

What characterizes someone being mortally threatened by moe? There's already a nosebleed tag...

I saw this tag a while ago and would have removed it from all images present, except it seemed (superficially at least) to have been unilaterally added by Bansho, who's a privileged user - thus, I figured there was some good reason for it, perhaps the name of a meme, or something, though I don't really see much of a connection between the pics so tagged.

Well there is one pic tagged as such which is the actual original doujin page containing this, so I think the tag could be used for that, or other pics which actually contain the phrase. But the tag being used just to describe a girl's appearance is no.

Then again, if there are only 1 or 2 pics that actually contain the phrase, there isn't much point in it having its own tag.

Edit: nvm, looks like you already untagged the ones that don't contain the phrase. It's happily ever after.