So... why are the other magical girls bashing(?) on the Madoka girls? My curiosity demands that I must know.

KnightBlades said:
What? You mean it's not just random artists doing this? If its a reoccurring thing then maybe fans of other magical girl shows are butthurt that Madoka and friends have a better written and more deeper story than just fighting reocurring bland enemies and things that come from the Monster-O-matic?

Little harsh, don't you think? Really it's a common trope. You take two series of similar genres but characters of differing personalities, have them fight. It's nothing really new. Same thing went on back when Nanoha was a big thing, and every now and then artists get around to it with other series.

Rosencraft said:
Little harsh, don't you think? Really it's a common trope. You take two series of similar genres but characters of differing personalities, have them fight. It's nothing really new. Same thing went on back when Nanoha was a big thing, and every now and then artists get around to it with other series.

If it was that, then Cure Peace would be also battle damaged but she doesn't seem to have a single scratch on her compared to Mami. So it evident who the artist fa- nevermind...just saw the rest of their art. Madoka beat the living snot out of Cure Happy. Go with Rosencraft's answer bunkhead.

yeah, the artist isn't really favoring one or the other. Seeing the rest of the series, things have gone pretty even so far

of course, there are people who will think it is butthurt and whine and baw about it, but oh well, what's one to do about the butthurt people anyway?

looks like two sisters are fight to the death!

Mami will be fine as long as her soul gem is intact. If it becomes completely tainted though, things might go bad for Cure Peace. I hope she likes tea parties.

Funny how I don't see half as much discussion on this artist's related pic of Madoka strangling Happy.

Comartemis said:
Funny how I don't see half as much discussion on this artist's related pic of Madoka strangling Happy.

You'd think "it's possible for Mami Tomoe to lose a fight" wouldn't be a controversial statement...