Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Indy! said:

Unbreakable already handled that, but for future reference: go here, look up the pool in question, click "edit" on the toolbar along the top, and remove the post id of what you want to banish.

If you know the name or id of the pool you can also use it like a meta tag in the tag box, tagging -pool:16535 or -pool:Gochuumon_wa_Usagi_Desu_ka?_-_Is_the_Order_an_Adult_Cocoa?_(KS_(xephyrks)) will remove the post from the pool. The reverse is also true in that you can quick add a post to a pool by tagging it with those sans the - sign.

Unbreakable said:

If you know the name or id of the pool you can also use it like a meta tag in the tag box, tagging -pool:16535 or -pool:Gochuumon_wa_Usagi_Desu_ka?_-_Is_the_Order_an_Adult_Cocoa?_(KS_(xephyrks)) will remove the post from the pool. The reverse is also true in that you can quick add a post to a pool by tagging it with those sans the - sign.

I figured there was a much simpler method but didn't know about it. Thank you!

Hello.

A few days ago I posted post #4387793 along with 5 related images. All 6 imaged were reviewed and disliked by 10 of 10 reviewers and I am unsure why. I tagged them and provided sources to the best of my ability. In addition, the artist who drew them misoba_kamazirou has a decent number of works posted on this site as well.

I am unsure what it is that I am doing wrong and I wanted to get feedback before going to the appeals thread.

A few days ago I posted post #4387793 along with 5 related images.

I think, because simple monochrome. It's hard to call it beautiful, cute, special.
More often, such works are uploaded by users with an unlimited level of publications, they can be part of a manga for a pool.

Kinzoku said:

Hello.

A few days ago I posted post #4387793 along with 5 related images. All 6 imaged were reviewed and disliked by 10 of 10 reviewers and I am unsure why. I tagged them and provided sources to the best of my ability. In addition, the artist who drew them misoba_kamazirou has a decent number of works posted on this site as well.

I am unsure what it is that I am doing wrong and I wanted to get feedback before going to the appeals thread.

There is something with her head/face (I think) that's really making it look weird and stops me from approving it, it's more obvious from the thumbnail. Other than that it looks fine.

Unbreakable said:

There is something with her head/face (I think) that's really making it look weird and stops me from approving it, it's more obvious from the thumbnail. Other than that it looks fine.

I think it is probably the mouth placement. But there's nothing I can really do about that. So... yeah. I'll just save these locally so I can still have them on hand.

Thank you for the feedback.

post #3409074 (Not my upload)

post #4393433
Official art, need advice

vivoleko01 said:

post #4393433
Official art, need advice

live2d art usually has a hard time getting approved, because it's often from a third party.

If it's official art you should tag it as such.

Was told to go here via the deletion message on my 2 most recently deleted uploads.

post #4390776

post #4393896

I don't understand anything wrong with these. No lack of quality, no NSFL stuff, etc.

post #4393924

I'm just going to assume this got deleted because it's just some random commission. I guess post #4395823 will also suffer the same fate because of it. *sigh*

post #4392161
post #4392174
post #4392183

Blasterfight said:

post #4392161
post #4392174
post #4392183

Koikatu stuff is always kinda meh. The animation looks boring and the characters itself generic or bad. By now that artist has only one approved image and that's really not a great animation. I would say it's better not to upload anything Koikatu related, as it has a hard time getting approved.

Blasterfight said:

post #4392161
post #4392174
post #4392183

Not that many approvers seem to be into loli and this isn't great quality. In the second post it looks like Rika's hands are nailed to the air and her leg looks extremely weird (also personally I don't like disembodied_penis). In the third post the guys movement looks unnatural.

SpiritOfRei said:

post #4390776

post #4393896

I can't speak for post #4390776, but in post #4393896 it looks like her left arm is extending from her hip.

post #4393924

I'm just going to assume this got deleted because it's just some random commission.

as a rule of thumb, sketches have a harder time getting approved because they don't contain the same level of detail as finished works.

Indy! said:

I can't speak for post #4390776, but in post #4393896 it looks like her left arm is extending from her hip.

as a rule of thumb, sketches have a harder time getting approved because they don't contain the same level of detail as finished works.

I guess you're right about post #4393896.

And for post #4393924, if sketches are kinda outlawed, then it's hard to believe the sketch tag has 90k+ posts under it ;w;

Thank god that post #4395823 got to live at least.

Blasterfight said:

post #4392161
post #4392174
post #4392183

The models are high quality but the animation is somewhat poor

SpiritOfRei said:

And for post #4393924, if sketches are kinda outlawed, then it's hard to believe the sketch tag has 90k+ posts under it ;w;

sketch is almost exclusively populated by unrestricted users.

SpiritOfRei said:

And for post #4393924, if sketches are kinda outlawed, then it's hard to believe the sketch tag has 90k+ posts under it ;w;

The sketch tag is mainly used for unfinished or rough artworks, like post #4401103 (notice the colours going sloppily over the lines), or artworks containing unfinished parts, like post #4400446.
I think the main problem is that your sketch is too much on the unfinished side. The lines are very simple, there aren't many details, there's no shading (unlike post #4366821 for example), and the background has very wonky lines.

Username_Hidden said:

The sketch tag is mainly used for unfinished or rough artworks, like post #4401103 (notice the colours going sloppily over the lines), or artworks containing unfinished parts, like post #4400446.
I think the main problem is that your sketch is too much on the unfinished side. The lines are very simple, there aren't many details, there's no shading (unlike post #4366821 for example), and the background has very wonky lines.

I understand. I'll refrain from posting sketches in the future then to avoid my profile looking bad with high amounts of unapproved posts.

post #4401258

Let me guess, bad perspective? Or is the art style not liked?