Damian0358 said in forum #438706:
They didn't come to it independently, they saw you doing stuff without discussion and following your lead, in janggab's case even doing so without considering tag naming standards. This is why I keep telling you to stop doing shit by yourself, because things can quickly domino and make a massive mess.
@janggab created tags for Manon's Outfit 2 and A.K.I.'s Outfit 3 on 2026-05-07. I created mine on 2026-05-09. They tagged before I did. I didn't even know they had done it until I started my own tagging.
Capcom's own designations outside of SFV, as I pointed out in forum #298915, suck ass.
I'm open to discussing naming conventions, but I think the official names should be the starting point, not something we invent. "Outfit 1/2/3" is what Capcom uses in-game and on their official social media. Capcom's own Twitter account posts things like "Outfit 3 is what Juri wears when she's chilling at home" with developer quotes attached. The SF6 community knows these costumes by these names. @sakurada_ichigo, who plays the game, confirms this forum #438705 . If we rename them to something Danbooru-invented, we're making them harder to find for anyone coming from the actual game community.
JP artists writing "Outfit #" in the actual artwork.
post #10298466
post #10763894
post #6929931
post #7782471
post #9526399
Examples of artists explicitly mentioning "Outfit #" in the commentary.
That said, I'd support sakurada_ichigo's suggestion of game-prefixing where needed for future-proofing — han_juri_(sf6_outfit_2) instead of han_juri_(outfit_2) — if the community prefers that. I'm not married to the current format.
In addition, because you avoided discussion, even if we were to accept SF costume tags, there is now a naming standard discrepancy between your tags and the ones Kikimaru made for this thread.
As for "avoiding discussion" — I wasn't avoiding it, I was preparing for it. This thread's history shows what happens when you propose costume tags without doing the groundwork first: 45 days of silence and an expired BUR. I needed populated tags, documented wikis, and visual references to have a discussion worth having. That's what I brought to the table. We're having the discussion now.
Looking at the wikis makes me argue that you're, per evazion's words, going overboard. I doubt most of these costume tags you made are notable.
evazion's "overboard" comment in the DOA thread was about palette swaps and minor variations. Every tag I've created is for an officially designated, purchasable/selectable costume that Capcom advertised and sold as DLC or included as a distinct outfit slot. If a game has 6 alternate costumes and they're all individually advertised and sold, they're all notable — that's not "going overboard," that's the complete set.
forum #411353 is illustrative of a number of tagging decisions made surrounding default costume tags, in that it needs to be difficult to find in order to justify their creation. The use of copytags in your search immediately undermines the potential for SF default costume tags, as people will be tagging the copytag the design debuted in first and foremost.
Copyright tags and costume tags serve different functions. han_juri + street_fighter_v tells you the art references SFV. It doesn't tell you which of Juri's multiple SFV costumes she's wearing — her default, her School Uniform, her Spider costume, or any other. The copyright tag identifies the game. The costume tag identifies the outfit. A user who specifically wants Juri's Spider costume has no way to isolate it with copyright tags alone.
And the copytag workaround still hits the 2-tag search limit for Members. han_juri + street_fighter_v already uses both tags, and you're still looking at every SFV Juri costume mixed together.
Killer Bee Cammy is nearly a 1k tag, but remove Zero from the search and you're left with posts that are just missing the copytag (killer_bee_cammy street_fighter_zero_(series)). The same can be said for han_juri_(nostalgia) -street_fighter_iv_(series), han_juri_(outfit_2) -street_fighter_v, and han_juri_(outfit_1) -street_fighter_6, regardless of the fact that they can appear in other games, because you'd then just do something akin to post #11278257, tagging the copytag the design is from and the game being referenced, thus making the World Tour argument null and void (especially with how little fanart we have that's explicitly World Tour-based).
That approach tags which games are being referenced but still doesn't identify which costume is being worn. If someone draws Juri in her SFV default in a SF6 context, tagging both copyrights tells you two games are relevant. It doesn't distinguish her SFV default from her School Uniform or any other SFV-originating costume. The costume tag is the only piece of information that actually answers "what is she wearing."
