Gonna be honest, I'm not really convinced we need meme attire. A wiki page to list all of the meme attires would suffice, but right now we're just dumping tons of different outfits under this gentag for no reason.
Posted under Tags
Gonna be honest, I'm not really convinced we need meme attire. A wiki page to list all of the meme attires would suffice, but right now we're just dumping tons of different outfits under this gentag for no reason.
nonamethanks said:
Gonna be honest, I'm not really convinced we need meme attire. A wiki page to list all of the meme attires would suffice, but right now we're just dumping tons of different outfits under this gentag for no reason.
Then what should we do? Deprecate meme attire as a tag, or create a dedicated pool, or something?
AkaringoP said:
BUR #41037 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
mass update golden_week_bikini -> -golden_week_bikini gold_bikini
As others mentioned earlier, I just don’t see any reason why this tag needs to be split off from gold bikini.
If someone really wants to document a trend from a specific time period, wouldn’t it be enough to leave a note on the gold bikini or golden week wiki page?
This is actually my first time seeing this tag, and I don’t think I’ll have any reason to look it up again.
golden_week_bikini (slingshot_swimsuit or one-piece_swimsuit)
nonamethanks said:
[..]
I cleaned this query out along with some straggler cases in golden_week_bikini -bikini which had some untagged cases of slingshot swimsuits and one slingshot swimsuit that was tagged as gold bikini when checking the latter. The remaining ~700 posts should all be safe to get this update made.
The bulk update request #41037 (forum #354401) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
AbsoluteRainbow said:
Then what should we do? Deprecate meme attire as a tag, or create a dedicated pool, or something?
Deprecating + mass update removing it from posts of the implicated tags should be fine, but it needs its own discussion topic because people might disagree.
BUR #41402 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
nuke golden_week_bikini
deprecate golden_week_bikini
Now this needs to be deprecated to stop it from being readded because @Jemnite repopulated the tag after it was nuked.
The bulk update request #41402 (forum #356989) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
BUR #41456 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
undeprecate golden_week_bikini
create alias golden_week_bikini -> gold_bikini
Actually, we should just make this an alias if people are actively tagging it/searching for it, so that they go to what they're searching for directly instead of having to do an intermediate jump.
The bulk update request #41456 (forum #357132) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
nonamethanks said:
Gonna be honest, I'm not really convinced we need meme attire. A wiki page to list all of the meme attires would suffice, but right now we're just dumping tons of different outfits under this gentag for no reason.
I think I have to agree, I'll make a new thread for this
nonamethanks said:
Actually, we should just make this an alias if people are actively tagging it/searching for it, so that they go to what they're searching for directly instead of having to do an intermediate jump.
That's actually a good move, it makes sense to redirect people to the same results.
BUR #41541 has been rejected.
create implication chronopattern_dress -> ai-generated_art_(topic)
The dress is ai-generated and not real.
Jemnite said:
BUR #41541 has been rejected.
create implication chronopattern_dress -> ai-generated_art_(topic)
The dress is ai-generated and not real.
The ai-generated (topic) tag was supposed to be used for posts making fun of AI artworks, or referencing AI in some form.
The dress being AI generated doesn't warrant the tag, partly because many artists probably drew it without thinking that it was made through AI.
Login_to_view said:
The ai-generated (topic) tag was supposed to be used for posts making fun of AI artworks, or referencing AI in some form.
The dress being AI generated doesn't warrant the tag, partly because many artists probably drew it without thinking that it was made through AI.
"A common use of this tag is for re-drawings of an AI-generated image that has gone viral."
I don't think an implication is necessary but it absolutely is in scope for the tag.
Edit: Actually it looks like this is standard, other similar tags imply it already.
The bulk update request #41163 (forum #355934) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.
Login_to_view said:
The ai-generated (topic) tag was supposed to be used for posts making fun of AI artworks, or referencing AI in some form.
The dress being AI generated doesn't warrant the tag, partly because many artists probably drew it without thinking that it was made through AI.
That doesn't necessarily apply, check the various tags that imply it already:
domino's pizza ai images (meme), ai-generated touhou, ai angry dr. mario (meme), italian brainrot ai animals (meme). We have examples like post #9209553, which don't reference AI at all, just has a shark with feet. In practice, the tag is just implied by anything that is a redrawing of/drawing including elements from an AI generation.
If that's the intended use case of the tag, then we should probably unimply a lot of these tags. Additionally, Ii don't think whether or not the art knows that the dress is AI generated should factor in case of tagging practices. Tag what you see, not what knowledge the artist is privy to.
Yeah I think ai-generated art (topic) has also become too bloated, like meme attire (forum #357163).
We should split it into somethingl ike ai redraw (for redraws of AI images, though it probably needs a better name) and a tag for posts that are actually about the topic in a meaningful way.
The bulk update request #41541 (forum #357485) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.