"qos" tag to contain all race play / "blacked" / queen of spades posts

The bulk update request #51578 (forum #402058) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.

Reply

BUR #51986 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

I've been procrastinating dealing with this thread because there's too much autism going on. Let's try a surgical approach. I'll reject all of the BURs here and propose some BURs divided by topic.

The tags involved in this topic are the following ones (not accounting for various proposed aliases):

OVERALL:
 race_fetishism
 
PEOPLE:
 blacked_female
 blacked_male
 femblacked 
 
PHRASES:
 blacked_(phrase) 
 bleached_(phrase) 
  
SYMBOLS:
 queen_of_spades_symbol
 queen_of_hearts_symbol
 king_of_spades_symbol
 jack_of_spades_symbol
 queen_of_pokemon_symbol
 queen_of_horseshoes 
 spade_vine_tattoo
 snowbunny_tattoo
 
MISC:
 blacked_parody

Let's try going through all the categories one by one.

An overall tag for the fetish involving raceplay

This is ok by me. Useful for searching and blacklisting alike. One thing I think we can all agree on, is that everything must be directly or indirectly implied to this tag for blacklisting purposes.
This should be easy enough. Just an utility alias. Implications will follow after in their own BURs.

Reply TheGamingRodent downtempo World Funeral CommentaryRequest user 1434626 user 881800 Hentai Addicted wingdings Nacha Historyanon trapster77 HyperOcram151817 LightSolas

nonamethanks

6 months ago

BUR #51987 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication blacked_female -> race_fetishism
create implication blacked_male -> race_fetishism
create implication femblacked -> race_fetishism

Subtags for the involved "people" (if you can even call them people)

I think it makes sense to be able to distinguish between these, if only because it's really hard to find the specific uncommon variants. One could argue blacked female is the redundant one, though if we nuke it then it'd be really hard to then filter down between sex posts and "innocuous" things like post #6200467, but it's pretty hard to find femblacked or blacked male without a billion exclusions, so they can stay.

I think femblacked is not a very clear name, but that appears to be what's used elsewhere. It's not accurate to call this reverse blacked, because that could be misunderstood for the bleached variant.

Another question is whether we need bleached female/male tags. The answer is no: there's likely too few posts for this. Such a distinction would only make sense if we started getting into the triple digits. However, I think it would be useful to have an overall reverse raceplay tag, for bleached posts in general, other than the bleached (phrase) tag.

A "blacked" subtag for race fetishism would be useless for the same reason: it'd just be 99% of race fetishism.

Reply TheGamingRodent World Funeral CommentaryRequest user 1434626 Hentai Addicted user 881800 wingdings Nacha trapster77 NeptuneStarPrime LightSolas

nonamethanks

6 months ago

BUR #51988 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication blacked_(phrase) -> race_fetishism
create implication bleached_(phrase) -> race_fetishism

The phrases

Not much to say here. These are fine to stay. Parodies can go to blacked parody.

If we ever get a bleached fetishism (or however we want to call it) tag, bleached (phrase) can go under that instead.

Reply TheGamingRodent World Funeral CommentaryRequest user 1434626 Hentai Addicted user 881800 wingdings Nacha trapster77 NeptuneStarPrime LightSolas

nonamethanks

6 months ago

BUR #51989 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication queen_of_spades_symbol -> race_fetishism_symbol
create implication king_of_spades_symbol -> race_fetishism_symbol
create implication jack_of_spades_symbol -> race_fetishism_symbol
create implication spade_vine_tattoo -> race_fetishism_symbol
create implication snowbunny_tattoo -> race_fetishism_symbol
create implication race_fetishism_symbol -> race_fetishism

How to deal with the various QoS tattoos derivatives

I see no harm in having king_of_spades_symbol etc. As long as they're unique enough, they're not harming anyone by just existing. Not like they'll be searched by anyone other than people with these fetishes.
The primary issue is that too much fragmentation means these tags would be too hard to see all at once or filter all at once.

The main problem with an umbrella tag is that queen of spades symbol is very large, which means it'd dominate any tag we make for it. Do we want queen of horseshoes and queen of pokemon symbol implicated to it? Or do we want it to be specifically only for the QoS symbol itself, and leave the rest alone or under blacked parody?

I think a good compromise would be to have a race_fetishism_symbol tag. I don't know if we should expand it to the blacked/bleached phrases to it, but I think that'd start making it too wide of a tag.

I am calling it symbol and not tattoo because these symbols don't necessarily have to be tattoos - they could appear anywhere, including necklaces or bracelets.