Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Would like to know the reason for the deletion of post #5827864, post #5827810 and post #5827834. Until now, every comic from marugoshi teppei was approved and all of the sudden three get deleted at once.

I've had 3 posts deleted with no reason given, could someone tell me what im doing wrong?

I undeleted a bunch of the recently asked about posts in this thread, don't have the time to reply to each poster but the ones I undeleted were fine.

post #5819143
post #5824416
post #5828748
post #5828827
post #5828921

chara1 said:

post #5819143
post #5824416
post #5828748
post #5828827
post #5828921

Main issue with these is that they're very sketchy. post #5819143 has pretty bad hands.

Does sketchiness on its own really justify bad quality ? In the right hands, it would be considered a stylistic choice instead.
In particular for most of these here, I'd say the colouration and composition more than makes up for it.

Thank you, nonamethanks!
Have to about again though, about post #5833320 this time

Hi, I would like to ask why none (literally none) of my recent tsukishiro_saika uploads didn't get approved at all.

There are a lot of works from this same artist, I also added some variations from already approved posts, so, ¿what is wrong with the ones I uploaded?

post #5818157
post #5818151
post #5818149
post #5817232
post #5817227
post #5817196
post #5817132

I was planning to upload more from the same artist, but since none got approved, I expect the same for the other uploads.

Thanks in advance

oggar said:

Thank you, nonamethanks!
Have to about again though, about post #5833320 this time

The dude is built like a titan from attack on titan, hard not to notice it.

gama_36 said:

Hi, I would like to ask why none (literally none) of my recent tsukishiro_saika uploads didn't get approved at all.

There are a lot of works from this same artist, I also added some variations from already approved posts, so, ¿what is wrong with the ones I uploaded?

post #5818157
post #5818151
post #5818149
post #5817232
post #5817227
post #5817196
post #5817132

I was planning to upload more from the same artist, but since none got approved, I expect the same for the other uploads.

Thanks in advance

Approved the two solo pictures, but the sex ones have weird looking torsos and faces.

I was trying to branch out to where I was posting my artwork and remember this lil gem of a site. however I keep having my post deleted and marked as low quality. I am assuming its because I watermark my artwork? Ive had issues with theft and my work being sold by others before.

nonamethanks said:

Approved the two solo pictures, but the sex ones have weird looking torsos and faces.

Thank you for the approved ones, and the feedback.

I was starting to think, that those weren't approved, because they were related to rape.

I was going to appeal directly from the button, but I prefer to ask a moderator about it here, i don't understand why the following image was not approved, the artist is ok, the image has a decent artistic quality, it is correctly tagged, the image is of good resolution, and it has been fully translated, both the comment and the text inside the image...
I guess it was a mistake, but if it wasn't, could you point me to the mistake, so i can avoid doing it again in the future? Thanks in advance.

post #5839105

Edit: Thank you very much for the review, the image was approved.

I could use some feedback. I'm learning as I go

(1) post #5843268
(2) post #5842546
(3) post #5831378
(4) post #5826358
--Comic--
--(5a) post #5742847
--(5b) post #5742848
--(5c) post #5742849
--(5d) post #5742850

post #5843871
post #5843805
post #5843799

Did I upload it at a bad time or is it a skill issue?

post #5846096
post #5814613

just curious about these two since the other enpe and sanazura_hiroyuki artworks seemed to be approved with no problem

Why was post #5853496 taken down?

skywalkerred said:

Why was post #5853496 taken down?

Paid rewards are against the rules and banned when they're posted.

post #5846247
Sourcing this is quite complicated as the artist who made the request has no intention of publicly posting this, although he has permitted me to repost it elsewhere. How should I properly source this?
post #4585201
Much earlier post but this was properly sourced and even approved but its status made it so it got deleted for no real reason other than "unapproved in 3 days".

post #5806685
post #5843369
post #5843879
post #5846421

I don't understand why they are deleted, especially the last one, which I uploaded together with another one, the other passed but that one did not.
What is missing to be approved?

Could you please give post #5848728 and post #5848661 a second chance?
What is it about the second one that makes it low quality?